Mushrooms in Sour Cream: Again

February 21, 2010 § 6 Comments

I briefly posted about this timeless classic before, but I don’t think I was getting through to you guys. So let me try again.

Mushrooms, sauteed in butter with caramelized onions, shallots and garlic, and drowned in sour cream and lemon juice, are among the most amazing foods I’ve ever tasted. The deeply-flavorful combination of sweet-yet-pungent alliums, woody, earthy mushrooms, and tangy sour cream and lemon is an experience that is… profoundly sensual to say the least. The pleasure I derive from having them is so intense, it makes me want to cry out in ecstasy. Or weep. Or otherwise express my deep satisfaction.

You’ve got to put my mushroom obsession in perspective though. When I was growing up, mushrooms were a rarity and in fact I don’t think I ever tasted one until I was visiting Latvia at the age of eleven, just around the time of the Putsch of August 1991 that have effectively put an end to the Soviet Union as we knew it (and a good riddance it was). Although food choices back home were absolutely incredible in their variety (think Turkish bazaar), mushrooms were not one of the things that commonly grew where I was, perhaps because of the uncompromisingly waterless desert climate, and I don’t ever remember encountering them at otherwise abundant farmer’s markets in the city. It is perhaps that flare of exoticism that fueled the life-long obsession. That and the Russian literature, that constituted the majority of my reading material when I was growing up.

(To ease your certain confusion, let me quickly walk you through my cultural background again: I grew up in Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan was once a Russian colony. Then it was a Soviet Republic.

The two languages of Azerbaijan are Azerbaijani (a close relative of Turkish that shares a lot of the vocabulary with Russian, Arabic, and Farsi), and Russian.

Over half of all the schools used Russian as the language of instruction, which is what I went to school in. So my first language is Russian.

But ethnically, I am neither Russian nor Azeri. I am Jewish. My mother grew up speaking Yiddish. My Jewish family moved to Azerbaijan from Poland and Ukraine and haven’t been there for more than three generations.

None of my family is back in Azerbaijan anymore.

I went to the American University in Bulgaria for my four years of college after I won a full scholarship there. As a result of my studies and travels, I speak six languages. Or I did once.

I met my husband at the said university in Bulgaria, where he headed after two years at the Deep Springs College. He was once a cowboy who made his own chaps.

My husband is a native of the Driftless Area of Wisconsin. That’s why I live in Wisconsin now.

Driftless Wisconsin, at least in my mind, is the undisputed heaven on earth – the land of milk and maple syrup. For that reason, I am among the luckiest people you’ll ever meet.)

Not sure why you needed that lyrical digression, but there it is. Now back to the mushrooms. And the Russians.

It is no secret to the readers of the Russian classics that the Russian soul is as deeply espoused to wild mushrooms as it is to caviar and religious mysticism – mushrooms-in-sour-cream motif is definitely something you come across over and over again. It wasn’t until moving to Wisconsin at the age of 23, however, that I finally had access to a variety of wild and cultivated mushrooms, and I plunged right in with the aid of this marvelous cookbook with a ridiculous title and pseudo-Chagall cover art.

Mushrooms in sour cream are amazing not only because they are heart-wrenchingly delicious, but also because they are a breeze to make and are versatile in their use. You can use them as a hearty topping for steak. Or hamburgers. Or instead of duxelles in beef Wellington. Or directly on toast for a simple lunch or even a light supper. Or as pasta sauce. Or eat them with a fork, though they are a bit too rich for that even for me.

When it comes to choosing mushrooms for this dish, I try to stay away from the placid white button ones. I go for a mixture of darker colored, more flavorful guys. Seasonal morels are obviously a wonderful, free, and rare treat, but when faced with a food cooperative aisle, and not wanting to purchase the expensive shitakes, I usually buy a combination of a 1-2 large portabellos and a handful of crimini mushrooms.

In choosing the alliums, I would say go with 1 onion (cippolini would be great), 1 shallot, and a clove of garlic or two.

Now let the magic begin:

Slice all the onion/garlic stuffs and saute them in a large amount of butter until they have caramelized and begun to brown. I would use 1/4 stick of butter for a combo of 1 onion, 1 shallot, and 1 garlic clove. (Unfortunately, I haven’t snapped a picture of this stage).

Add the sliced mushrooms to the caramelized onions (you might have to add more butter at this point), and cook over low medium to low heat until all the liquid has evaporated (if any), and the mushrooms have softened and began to brown. In this picture, I have 2 large potabello mushrooms and about 2 cups of criminis.

Dump in a generous dollop of sour cream and turn off the heat.

Stir in the sour cream, and add salt, black pepper, and a dash of lemon juice.

Pardon my not-so-attractive crumbs on the background... Remember how I told you I am the world's worst bread slicer?

Here’s what they look like if a picture is taken with a flash.

I know I should take a moment and style my food a little bit before I snap a picture... but all I could think was how I couldn't wait to start devouring those.

Here’s what they look like if a picture is taken without a flash. I couldn’t decide which one did this wonderful dish more justice, so I decided to post both. Still trying to figure out that photography thing.

Serve in any of the suggested ways, or some other creative ways you might have come up with. Then come back and tell me.

Tagged: , ,

§ 6 Responses to Mushrooms in Sour Cream: Again

  • Phoo-D says:

    This is pretty much my idea of a perfect meal! I adore mushrooms and with cream and lemon- delicious.

  • julia says:

    Hey, your cultural background doesn’t confuse me at all! (My grandfather’s family lived in Baku for years, although originally they were from Ukraine, and later immigrated to Israel.)

    The mushrooms look great.

    • Sofya says:

      No I bet it doesn’t confuse you, because you are of the same cultural stock. However, it often confuses my American friends – in part because the part of the world is so very obscure. For instance, because I met my husband in Bulgaria, very many people still think I am from Bulgaria – it’s common for me to hear them say “You are NOT FROM BULGARIA????????” Also people don’t quite know what to expect from me culturally – and I am an eccentric person with peculiar habits on top of that. I’ve began reading Moby Dick, and I very closely identify with Queequeg, the “savage” that Ishmael is trying to understand.

  • Paula says:

    I was intrigued and happened to have a half lb of shitakes without a plan, so I made this last night (without copying the recipe, so there were numerous changes, but the concept stayed pretty much the same). It’s good! Last night I had it on pasta. Today’s leftovers are on a purple potato.

    Love this blog! There are SO many recipes I plan on trying!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Mushrooms in Sour Cream: Again at The Girl's Guide to Guns and Butter.